Good, Bad, and Ugly Report: Duke

This is a prime example of why games are played on the field and not on the stat sheet.

UNC dominated Duke in nearly every statistic – total offense, turnovers, first downs, time of possession – and yet had to sweat out a final possession by the Blue Devils to secure its 20th win in the last 21 tries in this series.

For the most part, UNC’s effort was sloppy but was good enough to beat a Duke team that would finish 3-9. Carolina was plagued by penalties and the kind of mental miscues that have followed them most of the season. Still Carolina eked out a win and a third-straight winning season.

Thus follows this week’s GBU report:

GOOD

T.J. Yates: The senior ended his regular-season with a flourish, an efficient 28-35 effort for 264 yards and a touchdown. Duke essentially took away his deep looks and he wasn’t able to connect on the few looks he did get, but he did pass for over 3,000 yards this season and over 9,000 in his career.

Anthony Elzy: The story of UNC’s running backs is very impressive, considering the season Johnny White had in place of Ryan Houston and Shaun Draughn, and then what Elzy has done in relief of the injured White. Elzy had a career-high 116 yards on the ground and caught another four balls for 21 yards.

Dwight Jones: Yates was finally able to hook up with his top receiver, to the tune of 11 catches for 121 yards.

Casey Barth: Though he missed a 41-yard field goal, a shout-out goes to Barth as he set a school record for most consecutive extra points made.

Third downs and turnovers: Two of the key stats between UNC’s wins and losses this season, Carolina converted 11 of 17 third downs and had two takeaways while not turning the ball over themselves.

BAD

Kick coverage: This continues to be UNC’s worst area of special teams. Carolina gave up 13 yards on one punt return, which is crucial when C.J. Feagles is only averaging about 38 yards per punt; the Heels also gave up 36 yards on a kick return. I guess this is an improvement given that a punt return for a touchdown turned last week’s game.

ESPNU: OK, I get that ESPNU is the Worldwide Leader’s C-team at best, but the incorrect graphics, listing Bruce Carter as an impact player when he wasn’t even playing, and the general Pam Ward/Danny Kannell experience made me glad I watched most of the game on my DVR.

UGLY

Penalties: UNC was flagged 10 times for 74 yards, but that was not a real measure of the damage done because a number of those penalties were inside the 20-yard line and were half-the-distance types. For some reason, UNC-Duke games are hardly crisp, efficient affairs but the lack of focus and discipline, especially from experienced players, is troubling.

Safeties: For the second-straight game, UNC gives up a 4th-quarter safety. Really? Lots of teams don’t give up two safeties all season, if that.

**********

So, to borrow a line from Nuke LaLoosh in “Bull Durham”, winning is in fact better than losing, and the significance of three straight winning seasons cannot be discounted, given that it has only happened three times since the Choo Choo Justice era. The Heels will now await a bowl selection and hopefully have four weeks of practice to get healthy and polish the issues that have plagued them through most of November.

Tar Heel Fan

Good, Bad, and Ugly Report: NC State

If nothing else, you can count on UNC/NC State games being pretty close ones.

For most of the series history, which now totals 100 games, the margin of victory is often very close and this year’s edition was no exception.  UNC led early and ended the game dominating the stat sheet, but a fluke 4th down Hail Mary and a punt return for TD gave the Wolfpack a come-from-behind win.

It’s hard to get past the raw emotion of losing a game in this manner, but looking beyond the final score, UNC actually did some things very well, Unfortunately, the final score is all that matters.

Still, trying to find the positives in an otherwise gut-wrenching loss, here is this week’s GBU report:

GOOD

Taylor Jonathan Yates: Think his “I am a Tar Heel” promo will get booed now? Yates did everything he could to will his team to victory, going 33-44 for 411 yards and 2 touchdowns, most of that with white shirts in his face or scrambling for his life or getting knocked on his can. Yates is now UNC’s career passing leader in pretty much every relevant category.

Anthony Elzy: You can’t ask much more from your 4th-string running back. He posted 210 yards of total offense (172 receiving but only 32 rushing).

Casey Barth: Connor’s little brother was 4-4 on field goals, including a career-long 49-yarder. Barth is now 13-15 for the season on field goals.

Defensive game plan: Giving credit where it is due, Everett Withers and his staff had a solid game plan for the Wolfpack. UNC brought pressure successfully and flushed and hurried Russell Wilson while notching four sacks.

Jabari Price: The true freshman was picked on repeatedly last week against Virginia Tech, and State tried to do the same on Saturday. This time Price was up to the task and had a couple of key defensive plays that bode well for the future of the secondary.

BAD

3rd-down conversions: UNC was 3-15 on 3rd down, including 0-for its last 9 attempts.

Red-zone offense: And this is why red zone percentage is misleading – UNC was 100% (4-4) in the red zone, but only scored one touchdown. NCSU was also 4-4 in the red zone, but scored TDs on 3 of their 4 chances. If UNC converts just one more TD, that covers the final margin.

Running game: UNC only generated only 46 yards from its running backs on just 18 attempts. After a while, you just start throwing the ball because running gets nothing.

UGLY

Offensive line: Less than 3 yards per carry rushing. Seven sacks surrendered. Most of the time the O-line was simply overwhelmed by an undersized Pack D-line and their linebackers. A completely putrid, embarrassing performance.

Kick coverage: UNC gave up 188 yards on only 7 kick and punt returns, including the game-changing 87-yard punt return for a touchdown. State’s entire offense only gained 275 in 62 plays.

*****

This will be the point at which I encourage you to not be like your lupine cousins and put all the emphasis on this one single game, even though I know this kind of loss is gut-wrenching. Should UNC win at Duke next week and win the bowl game, the Tar Heels will have posted their 3rd-straight 8-win season for only the 3rd time since the Choo Choo Justice era. And they will have done it against an aggressive schedule with a QB few thought should start in August, a 4th-team running back, a 3rd-team fullback, 2nd-team tight ends and H-backs, and true and redshirt freshmen peppered all throughout the defense.  A team that was hampered by suspensions and has been crippled by injury still has a shot at an 8-win season. That’s impressive. Regardless of how or why the situation occurred, you can only play the hand you’ve been dealt and for the most part UNC has played it well.

There is still important football to be played this season, and plenty of issues to be sorted out after the season. So now UNC has to go back to the drawing board to snap this two-game losing streak, and Tar Heel fans just need to focus on something they are pretty good at: hating Duke.

Tar Heel Fan

Good, Bad, and Ugly Report: Virginia Tech

Six turnovers. Only one catch by one of the ACC’s top receivers. Over 400 yards of total offense surrendered. Bizarre penalties and official rulings. And yet UNC was not blown out. Sadly, that final fact may be one of the “good” highlights in this week’s GBU report.

The game was a tale of two halves: the first half, where UNC moved the ball well, held Virginia Tech to a trio of field goals, and held a slim halftime lead; and the second half, where UNC had five turnovers, back-breaking penalties, and blown and broken defensive coverages.

In the end, the Hokies rose to the moment and the Tar Heels did not. It was an unfortunate step backwards in a season where things had generally been moving forward from week to week.

Although this may be weighted more towards the back end, here is the GBU report:

GOOD

Anthony Elzy: Elzy had 184 yards of total offense despite not getting many touches for late in the 2nd and most of the 3rd quarters. But like much of the rest of Carolina’s day, his effort will be defined by a goal-line fumble that was kicked out-of-bounds by VT but by rule resulted in a touchback. The good news is that his effort likely means Ryan Houston’s redshirt is safe.

BAD

Dwight Jones: One week after a record-setting performance, UNC’s top receiver was held to one catch for only four yards. VT took away Carolina’s vertical passing game and two of T.J. Yates’ interceptions came from trying to force the ball to Jones.

Defensive front: I understand that most of the first half was spent with UNC only rushing four while dropping seven into coverage, but the defensive line got no push and barely made the Hokie linemen break a sweat. There were times where the five VT O-linemen had the four UNC D-linemen stood straight up like a practice drill.

Ryan Taylor and Ed Barham: Normally reliable receivers for Yates, Taylor was skunked and Barham had three catches for 22 yards. In other words, they combined for as many catches (3) as penalties (3).

T.J. Yates: He really could go in either category, but Yates still completed more than 50% of his passes for nearly 200 yards while getting zero help from his receivers.  On the other hand, he threw as many interceptions (4) in this game as he has thrown all season (4) and made really bad decisions. What are you going to do?

UGLY

Third quarter: UNC suffered a complete implosion on the field on both sides of the ball in the third quarter. It was interesting to watch in the same way that You Tube videos of skateboarders falling and racking their clusters are interesting to watch.

Defensive backs: Kendric Burney still does not seem to have it together after his long layoff, but Deunta Williams and Da’Norris Searcy stunk it up plenty as well. I saw more blown coverages between the three seniors in one half than I have in the past two years and before it was over, Williams and Burney were arguing and pointing fingers at each other. VT also made a concerted effort to throw at Jabari Price early and often, though the true freshman did make a great play in the end zone to save a TD.

Nuts and bolts: There are still too many little things that this team does wrong week in and week out that should be corrected by the 10th game. Nearly every game you can count on getting an illegal formation penalty, and this week UNC lost a key first down because an otherwise eligible receiver was covered up and therefore ineligible. These kinds of mental issues fall directly on the position coaches and coordinators and should be cleaned up in practice.

As bad as it stings to lose and look bad in the process, UNC is still where the pundits predicted they would be before the NCAA and academic unpleasantness began – looking up in the standings at VT, Georgia Tech, and Miami, plus a loss to a top-10 LSU team. Yet there is still plenty to play for in this season, including a chance to throw a big kink in NC State’s big-game hopes and the ever-present opportunity to remind Duke they are a basketball school. A 2-0 finish puts this team at 8 regular-season wins for a 3rd straight year, which is the kind of consistency this program has dreamed of since the Mack Brown days.

Tar Heel Fan

Good, Bad, and Ugly Report: FSU

The T.J. Yates show made an appearance in Tallahassee as the much-maligned senior quarterback put his team on his back and led UNC to a thrilling 37-35 win over Florida State. Yates is now the school-record holder for a single game passing performance with 439 yards – and could have had nearly 500 if he had not overthrown Ryan Houston at the end of the first half by a yard.

But beyond that, there is a lot to be said about the character of this team. Regardless of the source of the turmoil surrounding this team, those players who remain have shown the type of guts not seen in a Tar Heel team during some of the darker years of the program. And whether or not you agree with some of the calls by coordinators on either side of the ball, the fact remains that this UNC team has won a couple of games they would have lost in previous years.

With this as a backdrop, here is this week’s GBU report:

GOOD

T.J. Yates: What more can you say? Not only 439 yards, but on 24-35 passing. He now is the only Carolina QB to have two 400+ yard games in his career, and both are this season. He has thrown 15 TD passes and only 4 interceptions, and has 7 completions this season of over 50 yards. He has the two top passing performances in the ACC this season, and is now in the top-15 all-time career passing in the ACC. Yates HAS to be in the discussion for 1st-team all-ACC, right? Right?

Dwight Jones: Legit. No question about it. Jones hauled in eight catches for a career-high 233 yards and a TD. Again, he has to be in the 1st-team all-ACC discussion.

Hunter Furr: Way to answer the bell. It is an old adage in coaching that you need to be ready always because you never know when your number will be called, and the sophomore showed why with a game-high 27 yards on 3 runs in the game-winning drive.

Joshua Adams: Career-high five catches for 91 yards and a TD. This team needs a #2 receiver and if Jhey Boyd and Erik Highsmith don’t want to be that guy, then it might as well be Adams.

Casey Barth: The kicking game has been a question mark, but Barth made three field goals, including a career-long 46-yarder and the game winner. He has also made 63 consecutive extra points. My apologies in advance for jinxing him next week. Only the kick out-of-bounds marred an otherwise great game for Barth.

Second-half defense: After giving up 28 points in the first half, the UNC defense settled in and allowed less than 100 yards to the ‘Noles, with the only score coming after the botched punt snap.

BAD

Rushing performance: UNC running backs rushed for only 70 yards on 21 carries, and if you toss out Furr’s contribution on the last drive, it’s 43 yards on 18 carries. Amazing to think the offense scored 37 points with practically zero production on the ground.

Punting: This is an average grade. Obviously the bad snap that nearly cost the Tar Heels the game falls in the ugly category, but the coverage and net punting wasn’t that bad. On five punt returns, FSU gained only two yards. C. J. Feagles’ punts aren’t that long, but they are being covered well and Feagles’ net was actually better than FSU’s.

UGLY

Injuries: Unbelievable. One of the best stories in ACC football this season, Johnny White, is lost for the season with a broken collarbone. Shaun Draughn was also injured and his status is unknown. The temperature on Ryan Houston’s redshirt is increasing – hope it doesn’t burst into flames.

Penalties: UNC had 9 penalties for 56 yards, including one that nullified an interception.

And now the two hottest teams in the ACC will meet next Saturday in Chapel Hill. Virginia Tech has won 7 straight since starting 0-2 and losing to FCS James Madison. UNC, meanwhile, has won six of seven (losing only at Miami). The Tar Heels finally broke through and defeated the Hokies on the road last season, so hopefully that positive mojo will hold at home as well.

Tar Heel Fan

Good, Bad, & Ugly Report: William & Mary

The ampersand in the title is in honor of the College of William & Mary, which for some reason is almost always written with an ampersand and hardly ever as William and Mary.

It is somehow fitting that UNC’s game with William & Mary took place during the Halloween weekend because the game was somewhat of an illusion. A look at the stat sheet belies what actually transpired on the field. Carolina racked up over 420 yards of total offense, but 170 of those came in the 4th quarter. UNC was a season-best 9-16 on 3rd down but needed to be 2-3 on 4th downs to keep drives alive and crawl back in the game. T.J. Yates was a very respectable 23-33 for 238 yards and a TD (plus another rushing TD), but his one interception was very costly, giving the Tribe a short field and leading to their first touchdown.

On defense, the nightmare of attrition continues as Quan Sturdivant missed his 5th straight game and defensive backs Tre Boston and Mywan Jackson did not play and freshman backup Terry Shankle was injured during the game. But the defense put the clamps on in the second half limiting W&M to only 105 yards of offense.

Keeping in mind the following analysis may be as choppy and blurry as an ESPN3.com internet feed, here is this week’s GBU report:

GOOD

Johnny White: That’s Mr. Johnny White to you, who had a career-high 164 yards on the ground and another 23 receiving. White again put the anemic UNC offense on his back in the 4th quarter and had yet another dazzling long touchdown run, this time of 67 yards, to put the Tar Heels in front to stay. Again, hard to believe if not for the early issues surrounding Shaun Draughn and Ryan Houston, White may not have seen the field this season.

Dwight Jones: Jones had 9 catches for 107 yards. Guess we know who Yates’ new favorite target is. Jones is becoming a big-time receiver, even if he did not break a big one in this game.

Ryan Taylor and Ed Barham: This pair of seniors combined for 6 catches for 57 yards and a TD, helping fill in for the injured Zack Pianalto. It was good to see Yates targeting the tight end and H-back and these guys making catches.

An actual blitz: Defensive coordinator Everett Withers actually took the chains off his linebackers in the 4th quarter with a number of called blitzes and some speed rushing by the defensive ends. The result? Three sacks in the quarter and some actual bad decisions and hurried throws by a quarterback who didn’t have all afternoon to throw the ball and check down 7 times.

BAD

Erik Highsmith and Jhey Boyd: These guys combined for two catches for one yard. Really? Do you think Mark Stoops, Bud Foster, and Mike Archer won’t figure out a way to double Jones and make these guys beat FSU, VT, and NCSU?

Linebackers: Until Withers started walking up the linebackers and putting pressure in the 4th quarter, the linebackers were again non-factors as they were against Miami. This should be one of this team’s strengths and will need to step it up down the stretch.

UGLY

Offensive line: This group continues to be a glaring weakness, which is disappointing since they were supposed to be one of the most improved units on the team. They were pushed around most of the first half and it was not until the 4th quarter when the W&M defensive front started to run out of gas that holes really started to open up.

(Side note: it was pointed out in last week’s comments section that the O-line often shows up in the bad and ugly review while the running backs often show up in the good section and how can this be when the RBs obviously need the O-line to run. My response is A) I was an offensive lineman so I often grade them harder and they have not improved over the course of the season, and B) were Johnny White’s long TD runs last week the result of O-line play or his ability? Besides, take away White’s 67-yard TD run and he only had 97 yards on 28 carries, or less than 3.5 yards per carry.)

Fireworks guy: Indicative of much of UNC’s season, the fireworks that are shot off after a UNC score were set off after Casey Barth’s missed field goal in the 3rd quarter, resulting in the first documented fireworks fail in UNC football history.

Sometimes over the course of a football season, you just have to survive and move on to the next week. Of course UNC fans would have like to have seen the team come out focused sharp and easily handle a I-AA team, but William & Mary is a very good football team and the hangover from the Miami beating lasted longer than anyone would have hoped for. Still the Tar Heels were able to pull it together, eke out a win, and move forward. Now UNC has to get ready for a brutal three-week stretch in which they play the three top teams in the ACC with a combined record of 18-6.

Tar Heel Fan

The Good, Bad, and Ugly Report – Miami

It was bound to happen, you know.

For six games, UNC has fought through the adversity of suspensions, withheld players, and injuries to remain competitive and even cobble together a four-game winning streak, most against some pretty good teams. And then the wheels came off against Miami.

Everything that had worked for the Heels the previous four weeks pretty much didn’t happen Saturday night. Carolina had three turnovers, including two interceptions by T.J. Yates, who had only thrown one all season, and one by Anthony Elzy at the goal line that cost UNC at least a sure three points. UNC’s previously strong running game generated less than 150 yards.

Meanwhile, the “bend don’t break” defense broke as injuries took their toll on a squad already down two of this season’s starters, with two more players injured to the point that often UNC was frequently playing three freshmen in the defensive backfield. The defense couldn’t stop Miami on the ground or through the air, giving up nearly 450 yards of offense. The result was a thorough drubbing that will essentially cost the Heels a chance at the Coastal Division title barring unforeseen chaos among Virginia Tech, Georgia Tech, and Miami.

With that said, here is this week’s Good, Bad, and Ugly Report:

GOOD

Johnny White and Shaun Draughn: UNC’s two-headed running back monster combined for 156 yards on only 18 carries. White’s 76-yard touchdown run was a thing of beauty (and a shout-out to T.J. Yates for getting 60 yards down the field and trying to throw a block for White); the problem is his other 7 rushes yielded only 9 yards. White did not play most of the second half with a “stomach ailment”, giving way to Draughn who tallied 71 yards on only 10 rushes, but by that point the Heels were down and trying to pass.

Zach Brown: While UNC certainly needs Quan Sturdivant to return for depth, Brown has made the most of his time as he had an eye-popping 14 tackles against the Canes. Glad he decided to show up since Bruce Carter and Kevin Reddick were missing in action.

Kicking game: You know the “Good” section is thin when the kickers make the list, but maybe this is what the staff saw when incumbent Grant Shallock was benched in favor of C.J. Feagles. Feagles had three punts for only a 41-yard average, but none of his punts was returnable. Meanwhile, Casey Barth connected on his one chance at a field goal but more important but the ball in the end zone on kickoffs and Miami did not break off a long return.

BAD

Injuries: Already down three key players (Zack Pianalto, Quan Sturdivant, and LeCount Fantroy), Carolina lost Da’Norris Searcy, Mywan Jackson, Anthony Elzy, and Johnny White during the game. Already thin because of the unpleasantness and injury, the attrition was just too much to overcome. [UPDATE: Backup DL Jordan Nix, who had seen significant time this season, did not play and TE Ryan Taylor, who was filling in for Pianalto, left the game with a shoulder injury and did not return, bringing the total number of Tar Heels out or injured during the game to nine. That's a huge number for any team, much less one already missing nine players for other reasons.]

Any receiver not named Dwight Jones: Remember last season when it was thought Erik Highsmith might make UNC fans forget another receiver who previously wore #88? Heck, remember the LSU game when Jhey Boyd looked like a stud? These receivers are just not getting it done. Give credit to Miami’s defense, but this is an ongoing problem.

Freshmen defensive backs: The only reason this is not in the “Ugly” category is because you really can’t ask but so much of these guys. When you’re down to your 3rd and 4th-string D-backs, what are you going to do? These guys were out-played, out-athleted, out-hustled and made Miami’s receivers look like all-Americans.

UGLY

T.J. Yates: You can argue that he was due for a game like this statistically, but for the first time all season he made bad decisions, which he had not been doing prior. He had happy feet in the pocket and his two interceptions were forced throws. He was also throwing behind receivers and staring down his intended targets, which were things he did last year.

Offensive line: Part of the reason Yates had happy feet may have been because the Canes pretty much went through the Tar Heels’ offensive line like tissue paper. The O-line gave up 5 sacks and only opened limited holes for the running backs. This group is not getting better week-to-week and it is past the halfway point of the season.

Defensive front seven: Part of this issue goes to defensive coordinator Everett Withers’ apparent desire to never blitz (though to be fair, can you really run a corner or safety blitz with your 4th team freshman corners?) but the front seven put absolutely zero pressure on Jacory Harris, therefore not forcing him into bad decisions.

So, in a season held together with duct tape and twine, it was bound to come apart at some point. The William & Mary game couldn’t come at a better time. UNC has the chance to get healthy and take a break from a difficult stretch before the schedule turns downright brutal in November.

Tar Heel Fan

Minnesota GOP distracted by ugly Democrat babes

Remember the GOP talking point about how the upcoming November election is supposed to be all about jobs and the economy, and Minnesotans should really mellow out on meaningless distractio…
The Blotter